Topic: It is generally believed that some people are born with certain talents, for instance for sport or music, and others are not. However, it is sometimes claimed that any child can be taught to become a good sportsperson or musician. Discuss both views and give your opinion
Band 8.0 Discursive Essay
Whether innate talents or guidance and training play a more important part in the success of a sport star has drawn much attention from many people. In my opinion, mere talents would not fully determine one’s success but rather the nurture from teachers or trainers.
On the one hand, there are several reasons why some people believe it is talents that matter. Firstly, they believe that some particular skills could not be taught or trained, or at least they would take a considerable amount of time to be enhanced; and yet the odds for success are uncertain. The instinct or logical mind of chess players, for example, are usually seen as exclusive. Secondly, many people concede that hardwork does play a part in one’s success; however, inborn abilities are the root of greatness. There is convincing evidence of prodigies in the history of music such as Mozart that proves the validity of such a viewpoint. If he had been without the taste for music at an early age, he would not have become one of the most outstanding composers of all time.
On the other hand, I would argue that what dictates one’s failure or success is nurture. Any child with strong determination could be taught to excel in sports or music. Even if gifted, a person could easily turn his talents into no use without teaching and direction. Additionally, it is believed that everyone possesses his own hidden gifts which always need to be discovered and sharpened before actual acknowledgment. For instance, Adam Lambert, once stated incompetent at swimming, succeeded in standind among the best swimmers after non-stop guided training.
In conclusion, I agree with those who think it is possible to teach any child to become excellent at sports or music.